CENTRE FOR CAPITAL PUNISHMENT STUDIES

RSS
thepoliticalnotebook:

This Week in War. A Friday round-up of what happened and what’s been written in the world of war and military/security affairs this week. It’s a mix of news reports, policy briefs, blog posts and longform journalism.
News today: In Syria on Friday, the day after bombings killed 55, Assad’s government is calling for action on terrorism and the opposition is accusing the government of having ties with al-Qaeda forces.
On Tuesday, the UN released numbers stating that more than 80 Libyan refugees have died so far this year in their attempts to reach Europe.
Libya quietly passed a controversial amnesty law, offering a blanket pardon to any crimes committed by pro-revolution rebels.
Egypt seized dozens of heavy weapons bound for the Sinai peninsula at the Libyan border on Thursday.
Panetta has promised that no troops will be deployed to Yemen.
The story of the double agent sent by Saudi Arabia to disrupt and foil an Al-Qaeda suicide bomber plot and his successful infiltration strategy.
Turkey will not extradite fugitive Iraqi VP Tareq al-Hashemi.
Joost Hiltermann had a longreads piece on sectarian conflict in Bahrain up on NY Books. In Manama, protesters blocked roads with burning tires, demanding the release of female activist prisoners, some of whom have been being held for a year.
US Ambassador to Pakistan Cameron Munter is leaving his post after not even two years on the job.
The Red Cross is suspending its work in Pakistan pending a review after a ICRC health program manager was abducted and later killed in Balochistan.
Pakistan has successfully tested another short-range nuclear capable missile, the Hatf III Ghaznavi, and the second such in two weeks.
A cabinet of Pakistani officials will meet next week to consider reopening the NATO supply routes.
Monday, the Pentagon Inspector General released a report expressing concern over the Afghan National Army’s pharmaceutical distribution.
An AP-GfK poll puts public support in the US for the Afghan war at a record low of 27 percent.
The US is continuing to search for a Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, who was captured by insurgents in Afghanistan in 2009.
A rare bright news report out of A’stan: the UN is reporting that civilian deaths fell by 20 percent in the first four months of this year.
Russia is claiming to have foiled a terrorist plot against the Sochi Winter Olympic games in 2014.
In Honduras, days after the kidnapping and killing of journalist and gay rights activist Erick Martinez, another journalist named Alfredo Villatoro of HRN Radio was kidnapped on his way to work in the capital city of Tegucigalpa.
The GOP members of the House Armed Services Committee voted to include a provision in the new FY2013 defense budget that would ban same-sex marriage on military bases. HASC’s draft also failed to include mention of sequestration cuts.
Fearing Iranian nuclear capability, the GOP are pushing an East Coast missile defense shield.
The prospect of war with Iran is dividing the Israeli defense community, with Netanyahu and Defense Minister Ehud Barak leading a hawkish charge and numerous former intel chiefs publicly opposing them.
Reporting by Noah Schachtman and Spencer Ackerman for Wired reveals that the US military held a course (now cancelled) at the Joint Forces Staff College taught officers that “total war” need to be waged on global Islam. The professor’s presentation includes quotes like: “This barbaric ideology will no longer be tolerated. Islam must change or we will facilitate its self-destruction.”
On Wednesday, the FBI Chief said the recently thwarted bomb plot was a good reason to renew surveillance policies set to expire soon, extending the FBI’s abilities to spy on people abroad without a warrant.
Here’s your new to-be Chief of Staff of the Air Force: General Mark Welsh.
The Pentagon ceased cooperation with Marvel Studios on The Avengers because it did not treat military bureaucracy realistically (!).
Sgt. Major Teresa King, the first female commandant of the Army’s elite drill sergeant school, has been fighting for her job amidst a mix of accusations that she set unfair standards. The Army has now said these accusations aren’t substantiated. King is asserting that her gender was a cause for mistreatment at the hands of her superiors, whom she says actively campaigned against her.
Photo: Dover Air Base, Delaware. An Army carry team transports the body of Master Sgt. Gregory L. Childs of Warren, Arkansas, killed in Afghanistan. Steve Ruark/AP.

thepoliticalnotebook:

This Week in WarA Friday round-up of what happened and what’s been written in the world of war and military/security affairs this week. It’s a mix of news reports, policy briefs, blog posts and longform journalism.

Photo: Dover Air Base, Delaware. An Army carry team transports the body of Master Sgt. Gregory L. Childs of Warren, Arkansas, killed in Afghanistan. Steve Ruark/AP.

India

Jan. 28


INDIA:

1st death penalty in a drug crime case


In the 1st ever case of capital punishment in a drug crime, a special
Narcotics
court in Chandigarh has awarded death penalty to a person while sentencing
an
African national to 15-years of Rigorous Imprisonment (RI).

The court of Special Judge (Narcotic Drugs and Physchotropic Substances Act)

Shalini Singh Nagpal awarded death sentence to one Paramjeet Singh for
trafficking 10 kilograms of Heroin and supplying it to an African national
Sestus Benson in 2007.

Till now the maximum punishment in drug crime has been RI and a heavy fine.

“Paramjeet was arrested by the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) on November
30,
2007 in Chandigarh’s sector-39 as he was illegally delivering 10kg Heroin to

Benson. What made his crime grave was that Paramjeet was out on parole
granted
by a Delhi Court in another drug trafficking case,” NCB Special Public
Prosecutor Kailash Chander said.

This is a 1st-ever case of capital punishment being awarded in a drugs
trafficking case. Benson has been awarded an RI of 15 years and a fine of Rs

1.5 lakh by the court, Chander said.

NCB Zonal Director Rohit Katiyar confirmed the development to PTI and said
the
judgement in the case was historic and would act as a “deterrent in illegal
drugs and crime cases”.

“This is a historic judgement. The judgememnt will go a long way in curbing
the
menace of narcotics abuse in the country, especially amongst the youth,”
Katiyar said.

Paramjeet was earlier arrested by the agency in Delhi in 2005 and was
granted
parole by a Delhi Court and the Chandigarh court not only relied on this
fact
but also the NCB probe to deliver today’s judgement under the Prevention of
Illicit Traffick in Narcotic Drugs and Physchotropic Substances Act (PIT
NDPS),
Chander said.

(source: Hindustan Times)

Feb 7

YEMEN: Demonstrators demand to execute Yemeni president

Tens of thousands of people demonstrated Sunday in Sanaa, demanding the execution of Yemeni President Ali Abdallah Saleh and protesting against the law granting him immunity. The Yemeni Parliament on Saturday granted to Saleh “total immunity against any legal or judicial action.” It also endorsed the candidacy of Vice President Abd Rabbo Mansour Hadi in the presidential election, scheduled Feb. 21 in the country, which in the past year was rocked by unrest that left hundreds dead. Hadi is the only candidate for a 2-year interim term.

“No immunity at the expense of our blood,” read a banner brandished by the demonstrators, who tried to head to the U.S. embassy in Sanaa before being stopped by security forces .

The parliament amended the bill granting immunity to Saleh and his aides, based on an agreement signed to end the internal crisis. Under the new law, aides of Saleh, in power for 33 years and accused by protesters of corruption and nepotism, enjoy immunity “for politically motivated acts, performed in the exercise of their official duties.” However, immunity “does not apply to terrorist acts.”

The UN envoy to Yemen, Jamal Benomar, criticized Saturday night that law, emphasizing the right of “victims” to hold Saleh regime accountable. “The law was amended (…) but remains below our expectations. The UN has a principled stand against this kind of absolute immunity,” he said during a press conference.

He called to enact “a law on justice and reconciliation” that would allow “victims to claim compensation.”

(source: Albawaba News)

Feb 7

TRINIDAD & TOBAGO: ‘Govt working to implement death penalty’

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar says Government will work to implement the death penalty as part of a serious crime reduction tool.

Persad-Bissessar was delivering an address yesterday at the Ministry of National Security Planning Workshop organised by the Center for Hemispheric Defense Studies (CHDS) yesterday at the Hyatt Regency (Trinidad) hotel, Port of Spain.

With 30 murders in the first 21 days of the year, she said Government is aware of the upsurge in the homicide rate although it has been reduced significantly from 2009 to 2011.

“Despite the fact the statistics for 2011 reveal a decrease in homicide and serious crime, Government is appalled at the brutal nature of the crime. The cautious optimism with which we viewed last year’s statistics…should not be misinterpreted as complacency,” she said.

She said because of this the People’s Partnership government is prepared to use all the resources including the death penalty to vigorously pursue and contain criminal activity.

“To this end my government is committed to implementation of the death penalty which remains part of the laws of Trinidad and Tobago…We shall continue in our effort to facilitate the re-implementation of the death penalty so it might both punish the guilty and deter the would-be offenders,” she stated.

She said regrettably the Constitution Capital Offences Bill 2011 which required a special majority in Parliament did not receive the support of some members.

She said her Government that had introduced 11 other pieces of legislation to aid in combatting, including the Abolishing of the Preliminary Enquiry Act, the DNA Bill among others.

Persad-Bissessar said since her Government took office back in May 2010, it had been attempting to address “the tsunami of crime that has hit Trinidad and Tobago”.

“We have pledged to the people of this country that we are going to rid the country the scourge of criminal elements which have been allowed for too long to thrive and prosper on the decent, innocent and hard-working people,” she said.

She added that the Government was compelled to admit that criminal violence occurred too regularly.

Earlier in her address, Persad-Bissessar crime and violence threatened the welfare of citizens and economic growth.

Minister of National Security John Sandy said the workshop was aimed at developing a policy where the Caribbean Basin becomes a safer and more secure place to work, live and do business.

Attending the workshop were United States Ambassador Beatrice Welters, Commissioner of Police Dwayne Gibbs and various Government MPs.

At a People’s National Movement (PNM) general council meeting yesterday in Port of Spain, PNM Public Relations Officer, Senator Faris Al-Rawi, said it is untrue that the Opposition failed to give its support to the bill.

Al-Rawi said Government is the one that has failed by its refusal to move from the Privy Council system to the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ), which would deny criminals the right to have their final appeal subject to European and United Kingdom law.

“The move to the CCJ is a very important one,” Al-Rawi said.

(source: Trinidad Express)

Feb 7

Algeria demands death sentence for top Qaeda boss

Algerian prosecutors on Sunday requested the death sentence for Mokhtar Belmokhtar, a top leader in Al-Qaeda’s north African branch, and another person in a trial on the deaths of 2 Algerian soldiers.

Belmokhtar and nine co-defendants, of whom 4 are also on the run, are accused of perpetrating several “terrorist acts” including a May 2010 attack on soldiers in the southern Djelfa region that left 2 dead.

Belmokhtar, a native of central Algeria, is a founding member of the Salafist Group for Preaching and Combat (GSPC), which later became known as Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM).

He heads one of AQIM’s 2 main katibas (battalions), controlling the group’s southern area.

Prosecutors also sought capital punishment for Abdelkader Benchneb, the chief accused present in court. They urged 15-year jail terms for the others, defence lawyer Hassiba Boumerdessi said.

Algeria has observed a moratorium on capital punishment since 1993.

A ruling was due later Sunday.

Nicknamed “the uncatchable,” Belmokhtar rules over a large swathe of desert that straddles Algeria, Chad, Niger, Mali and Mauritania and where his men are believed to hold several Europeans hostage.

Belmokhtar has already been sentenced in absentia to life imprisonment in 2004 and 2008, and to 20 years in prison in 2007, over similar charges and the killing of 13 customs officers.

In November Belmokhtar told a Mauritanian news website that AQIM had acquired Libyan weapons during fighting that ended in the overthrow and killing of strongman Moamer Kadhafi.

He said AQIM was still demanding the withdrawal of French troops from Afghanistan in exchange for the release of its French hostages.

On January 2, an Algiers court sentenced Abdelhamid Abou Zeid, the leader of the other key AQIM katiba who is also on the run, to life in prison for creating “an international terror group”.

(source: Africasia.com)

Feb 7

Iran to execute programmer


Imagine you are a furniture retailer and one of your customers bought furniture from your shop for a brothel, unfortunately, police raid that brothel and they find the furniture used in there came from your shop. With that, you face charges of associating with prostitution and you’re sentenced to death.

Iran’s Supreme Court has rejected an appeal and upheld the death sentence for a web programmer who faces imminent execution for associating with porn websites.

Saeed Malekpour, an Iranian who hold permanent residency in Canada, was picked up by plain-clothed officers in October 2008, while visiting his relatives in Iran, and taken to Evin prison in Tehran, where he spent a year in solitary confinement without access to lawyers and without charge.

1 year after his arrest, the 35-year-old appeared in a state television program confessing to a series of crimes in connection with a porn website. On the basis of his TV confessions, he was convicted of designing and moderating adult materials online by a court in Tehran, which handed down death penalty.

Malekpour later wrote a letter to his wife from prison, in which he said the TV confessions had been made under duress. He was blindfolded, handcuffed and attacked by several individuals armed with cables, batons and their fists struck and punched him. At times, they would flog his head and neck. They forced him to write what the interrogators were dictating, and compel him to play a role in front of the camera based on their scenarios.

Speaking from Toronto in tears, Malekpour’s wife, Fatemeh Eftekhari, said her husband was a freelance web programmer who had written a photo uploading software that has been used by a porn website without his knowledge.

Eftekhari said, “Even if my husband’s charges were true, which they are not, it’s hard to imagine why he should be sentenced to death. If he was engaged in developing and administrating porn website as charged by the Iranian regime, why would he step into Iran?”

His sister, Maryam Malekpour, speaking to RFE/RL’s Radio Farda from Tehran on January 18: “All of Saeed’s activities were within the law, he didn’t commit anything illegal. Saeed just wrote a computer program to help others upload and manage their photos, and market it online; it could have been used by any website on the internet. Unfortunately, without his knowledge, the program was sold and used to upload photos on these immoral websites.”

“All the evidence they have against him is from his confessions,” she said. “Saeed was in solitary confinement for about one and a half years and was under extreme physical and emotional pressure. For sure, anyone who is in this condition and wants it to end will confess to anything they’re asked.”

Ms. Malekpour believes that one of the reasons behind her brother’s imprisonment and conviction could be his ties to Canada. Canadian media said he was awaiting citizenship at the time of his arrest. Canada has recently joined the United States and European countries in stepping up sanctions on Iran in recent months, amid mounting concern as its nuclear program and in response to the country’s abysmal human rights record.

Ms. Malekpour says her own letters to Iranian judicial officials defending her brother have gone unanswered. She has pledged to continue her efforts and says she remains hopeful.

The Iranian Supreme Court sentenced Saeed to death for ‘insulting the sanctity of Islam’, being responsible for ‘spreading corruption on earth’ and ‘threatening to destroy the Iranian nation’, a vaguely worded charge which attracted the death penalty in Iran.

Saeed’s sentence has prompted reactions from human rights activists and organisations who have launched a campaign to save his life. In a January 17 statement, Canadian Foreign Minister John Baird condemned the Iranian Supreme Court’s decision.

Gloria Nafziger of Amnesty International in Canada, an organisation that has sought for Malekpour’s sentence to be commuted said: “Amnesty International is very concerned that Saeed Malekpour is facing a death sentence in Iran after an unfair trial and reports that he was tortured in order to confess to his crimes.”

Maryam Nayeb Yazdi, a human rights activist based in Toronto, said, “Saeed is in imminent danger of execution. He has never been provided with a fair trial at any point during this horrific and twisted ordeal.”

(source: Zimbabwe Metro)

Feb 7

IRAN

Iranian authorities in 2011 carried out more than 600 executions and imprisoned more journalists and bloggers than any other country, Human Rights Watch said today in issuing its World Report 2012 Iran chapter. Iran’s judiciary works hand-in-hand with security and intelligence forces to harass, imprison and convict opposition and rights activists, despite increasing international condemnation of the country’s rights record.

In March the United Nations Human Rights Council appointed Ahmed Shaheed to be the first special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in Iran since 2002. Since Shaheed’s appointment the Iranian government has refused him entry to the country, executed more than 400 prisoners – including people convicted of committing crimes when they were children, and prosecuted dozens of outspoken lawyers, journalists, and rights activists for their peaceful speech and associational activities. In February the authorities placed the 2009 presidential candidates Mir Hossein Mousavi and Mehdi Karroubi under house arrest, where they remain.

“The Iranian government crushes all voices of opposition while scoffing at the international community’s growing concern over human rights,” said Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East director at Human Rights Watch.

In its 676-page World Report 2012, Human Rights Watch assesses progress on human rights during the past year in more than 90 countries, including popular uprisings in the Arab world that few would have imagined. Given the violent forces resisting the “Arab Spring,” the international community has an important role to play in assisting the birth of rights-respecting democracies in the region, Human Rights Watch said in the report.

In Iran, the authorities carried out more than 600 executions, according to several rights groups, even though the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights and four UN experts pressed Iranian officials for an immediate moratorium on the death penalty, “particularly for drug-related and juvenile cases.” Government sources announced only around 350 of these executions. The vast majority were for drug-related offenses, including trafficking and possession. The pace of executions accelerated following the entry into force in December 2010 of an amended anti-narcotics law, drafted by the Expediency Council and approved by Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

Despite the hundreds of executions, Yuri Fedotov, executive director of the UN Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), made no mention of the wave of executions taking place in Iran for drug-related offenses and praised the country’s anti-drug efforts during a visit to Tehran in July. The UNODC has provided up to $22 million since 2005 to support training projects for Iran’s anti-drug forces, and the European commission, European Union member states, and several other governments including Japan, Norway, Australia and Canada, provide money, technical assistance, and legislative support to Iran’s anti-drug efforts.

Iran also led the world in the reported execution of people convicted of offenses they allegedly committed before age 18, despite the prohibition on such executions under international law. Iranian law allows capital punishment for people who have reached puberty, defined as age 9 for girls and 15 for boys. The judiciary allowed the execution of at least 3 children in 2011.

Authorities have executed at least 30 people since January 2010 on the charge of moharebeh (“enmity against God”), for alleged ties to armed or terrorist groups. On January 9, 2012, a revolutionary court in Tehran sentenced Amir Mirzaei Hekmati, an Iranian-American, to death on charges of moharebeh, “corruption on earth,” and espionage. The judiciary sentenced Hekmati after authorities detained him for more than 4 months without providing him access to a lawyer, his family, or the Swiss consular officials who represent American interests in Iran.

As of December 42 journalists and bloggers were in prison in Iran, according to the Committee to Protect Journalists. More than 60 journalists were forced into exile in 2011 alone, and authorities have shut down at least 40 publications since 2009. On January 17, 2012, Iran’s Supreme Court confirmed the death sentence for blogger Saeed Malekpour, a Canadian resident who was convicted of “insulting and desecrating Islam” in October 2011. At least 2 other individuals have been sentenced to death by the judiciary on internet-related charges. The government blocks certain websites that carry political news and analysis, slows down internet speeds to hinder web access, and jams foreign satellite broadcasts.

In January 2011 a revolutionary court sentenced Nasrin Sotoudeh, a prominent rights lawyer, to 11 years in prison and barred her from practicing law and leaving the country for 20 years on charges of “acting against the national security” and “propaganda against the regime.” The judiciary later reduced her sentence to 6 years and a 10-year ban on travel and practicing law. The judiciary prosecuted, convicted, or sentenced several other prominent lawyers to prison terms and bans on the practice of law. Earlier in the year Sadegh Larijani, the Head of the Judiciary, warned lawyers that they should refrain from giving interviews that damage the government’s reputation.

On January 10, 2012, the Interior Ministry’s election commission disqualified several dozen candidates from running in the upcoming March 2 parliamentary elections because of their “lack of adherence to Islam and the Constitution.” The disqualified candidates include several incumbents who were critical of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s government. In November and December reformist and opposition activists, some of whom are currently serving prison terms, issued several statements calling the parliamentary elections a sham and concluding there was no reason to field candidates. In December the Iranian judiciary announced that anyone calling for a boycott of the upcoming parliamentary elections would be subject to prosecution.

Mousavi and Karroubi were placed under house arrest in February 2011 after they called for mass protests. Several days earlier, beginning on February 8, security forces had arbitrarily arrested dozens of political opposition members in Tehran and several other cities.

“The continued detention of Mousavi and Karroubi, not to mention the dozens of reformist candidates arrested after the disputed 2009 presidential election, is a reminder to all of us that Iran’s human rights crisis is linked to the demand of citizens to participate in free and fair elections,” Whitson said.

(source: human Rights Watch)

Feb 7

Iran using death penalty more and more, says HRW

Death penalty still persists in a number of countries worldwide.

CAIRO: Iran used the death penalty in an alarmingly increasing manner last year, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said in Cairo while launching their global rights report.

The New York-based organization reported that the country had the highest execution rate for minors.

Iran executed at least three children in 2011, one of them in public, while more than 100 juvenile offenders remain on death row, the report said. Iranian law allows capital punishment for those who have reached puberty, defined as 9 years for girls and 15 years for boys.

The number of executions increased after the entry into force in December 2010 of an amended anti-narcotics law. Since then, more than 400 prisoners were executed – including 67 drug offenders in January alone, HRW said.

Crimes punishable by death include espionage, sodomy, adultery and apostasy.

In 2011, Iranian authorities targeted lawyers, human rights activists, students and journalists; refused to allow regime critics to hold demonstrations and used force to break up massive demonstrations in Tehran and other major cities in support of the uprisings in the Arab world.

The New York-based group charged that the government continues to shut down newspapers, and target journalists and bloggers, accusing them of crimes such as “propaganda against the state.”

According to Reporters Without Borders, there were 49 journalists and bloggers in prison as of October.

Feb 7

EU condemns death sentencing in Gaza

BETHLEHEM (Ma’an) — The EU on Thursday urged the Gaza government not to carry out capital punishment after the Hamas-led administration sentenced two men to death in January.

In a statement, EU missions in Jerusalem and Ramallah condemned the death sentence handed down on Jan. 11 by a military court in Gaza.

The court sentenced a 48-year-old man to death on charges of collaboration and conspiracy to murder, the Palestinian Center for Human Rights said.

On Monday, a civil court in Gaza on Monday issued the death sentence to a 27-year-old man convicted of murdering his brother, the second death penalty ordered in 2012.

Since 1994, 25 death penalties have been issued in the West Bank and 98 in the Gaza Strip. The Hamas administration has issued 37 death penalties since it took control of Gaza in 2007.

The EU urged the Hamas government to refrain from carrying out any executions of prisoners and to comply with the de facto moratorium on executions put in place by the Fatah-led administration in the West Bank.

PCHR called for an immediate moratorium on the use of the death penalty noting that it violated international human rights standards.

It urged President Mahmoud Abbas “not to ratify such cruel and inhuman punishment.”

“The call for the abolition of the death penalty does not reflect a tolerance for those convicted of serious crimes, but rather a call for utilizing deterrent penalties that maintain our humanity,” PCHR said in a statement.

(Source: maannews.net)

Feb 7

USA- Forgiveness key in group’s fight against death penalty

JACKSONVILLE — There are some images that Bill Pelke can’t erase from his memory.

For years the picture in his head that haunted him was of his beloved “Nana,” Ruth Elizabeth Pelke, a woman who taught Bible classes to local children in her hometown of Gary, Ind. In 1985 she was stabbed 33 times by a group of local teenagers who stole 10 dollars from the 78-year-old woman and let her bleed to death on her living room floor.

It was the image in his head when he sat through the trial of Paula Cooper, the 15-year-old female who ended his grandmother’s life.

“I remember when they asked me how I felt,” Pelke said Thursday at Jacksonville State University, recalling learning that Cooper was to receive the death penalty. “I said, ‘the judge did what he felt he had to do, but it won’t bring my Nana back.’”

Pelke, 64, was the first of three speakers during an anti-death penalty forum called “A Journey of Hope,” sponsored by the campus Ethics Club. More than 30 people at Houston Cole Library listened to Pelke, Callie Greer, and a representative of the Birmingham-based Justice and Mercy group, Brandon Fountain, all present their stance against the death penalty. The event doubled as the first meeting of the semester for the club.

“We’re all about dialogue,” said Scott Beckett, the faculty adviser for the Ethics Club. “Because we’re human, everybody here already has made up their mind, but we’re about dialogue.”

But Pelke hoped his dialogue could possibly persuade death penalty proponents to change their mind — much as he changed his own stance on capital punishment after his grandmother was murdered. Pelke said his Christian upbringing taught him the death penalty was an acceptable form of justice, but began to question that notion in the years that followed Cooper’s sentencing.

Over time, the image of his grandmother, the one he carried with him through the trial of Cooper, was replaced by another image he couldn’t shake — that of Cooper’s grandfather, shouting out “they’re going to kill my baby!” after her sentencing.

Like Pelke, Callie Greer lost a loved one through violence. Her son, Mercury, was murdered in Birmingham, and just like Pelke, sought for forgiveness.

“They kill this boy, give him life sentence or whatever, does that mean Mercury is going to come back?” Greer said. “Are you telling me I should put his family through this to get closure? Now I get closure? Uh-uh, I get nightmares.”

Not all the details of the two stories were the same, though.

“Black on black crime is just treated as another case,” said Greer, explaining her story didn’t “make it to Oprah” like Pelke’s more famous story.

Fountain said Greer’s claims of racial bias in the death penalty process are supported by facts. Fountain, the final speaker, presented a case against death penalty using state statistics.

“There’s not a racial issue in Alabama’s death penalty?” Fountain asked the audience, pointing out that 35 percent of murder victims in Alabama are white, while 80 percent of death row inmates were found guilty of killing a white victim.

“Now how does that work?” he said.

The audience responded with applause, however, to Pelke’s tale about his grandmother, and finding a way to forgive the teenage girl who murdered her more than 20 years ago.

Since his turnaround on the issue of justice and the death penalty, Pelke started his own foundation and talks at forums and events all over the world in opposition to the death penalty. He said he made a promise to God to connect with Cooper and her family, to tell her about his grandmother’s life and do everything he could to save Cooper’s.

And on July 1, 2013, Cooper, whose sentence was reduced thanks to Pelke’s efforts, will be able to walk out of Indiana state prison — where Pelke will be there to greet her.

Now the image he can’t forget is the drive home after meeting Cooper in prison for the first time in 1994.

“The word that coming back to my mind was “wonderful,’” Pelke said. “Because after this terrible thing that happened to Nana, this terrible thing that happened to my family, I had no hate. Only forgiveness.”



Read more: Anniston Star - Forgiveness key in group’s fight against death penalty